Toronto Maple Leafs May Shift William Nylander to Top Line This Season

Toronto Maple Leafs are weighing a surprise line change: moving William Nylander onto the top line with Auston Matthews for the upcoming season. Analyst Jonas Siegel of The Athletic argues the winger’s skill set makes him the best candidate to partner the star center, a move that could reshape Toronto’s offensive hierarchy.

Why is Nylander a candidate for the top line?

Nylander posted 30 goals and 49 assists for 79 points in 65 games last season, proving he can produce at a high clip. His chemistry with Matthews dates back to their rookie days, when both skated together under Mike Babcock’s staff. Siegel notes that the pair’s connection faded after coaching changes, but a reunion could reignite that early spark. The winger’s speed and puck‑handling fit the fast‑paced style the Leafs aim to deploy.

How would the new top‑six look?

Siegel sketches a possible lineup: McKenna – Matthews – Nylander on the first line, with Knies – Tavares – Cowan anchoring the second. This configuration pushes McKenna to the left wing, giving him a chance to develop alongside the franchise center. The trade‑off is a weaker second line, which could leave depth concerns if the top line stalls. Still, the upside of a more potent first unit may outweigh the risk.

What does the Leafs’ current situation demand?

The club sits 15th in the Eastern Conference with a 32‑36 record and is riding a seven‑game losing streak. The urgency to spark offense is palpable as Toronto prepares for its next game against the Montreal Canadiens on September 19, 2026. General manager John Chayka has already signaled a willingness to chase additional star talent, emphasizing that “a general manager’s job is to star‑hunt, first and foremost.” Adding Nylander to the top line aligns with that philosophy, offering an internal upgrade without cap‑heavy moves.

Could the move change Toronto’s playoff chances?

If Nylander thrives with Matthews, the Leafs gain a line that can challenge any opponent’s defense. Opposing teams would have to contend with a high‑scoring duo that can generate chances from both the slot and the perimeter. However, the plan hinges on the second line maintaining enough production to keep the team afloat. A slump there could leave Toronto’s offense one‑dimensional, especially given the current losing streak.

What are the next steps for Toronto?

Coach Sheldon Keefe will likely test the pairing in preseason scrimmages before committing to a permanent shift. Meanwhile, the front office continues to explore external options, keeping the door open for further acquisitions. As the Leafs head into the Canadiens matchup, all eyes will be on whether the coaching staff dares to reshuffle the lines and give Nylander the top‑line spotlight.